Question for Cider?

[elio]

Hey Cider just a quick question for you (again!! sorry);

In you honest opinion both spec'd the same which character would you level 1st in TBC:

Elio:
http://ctprofiles.net/2051058

TinyElio:
http://ctprofiles.net/5005991. His DPS is this: http://ctprofiles.net/5006036

Thanks in advance

Elio

[elio]

Also note that I am the MT of the guild.